It appears that your cart is currently empty
cookies now available 24/7! new flavors every week!
How to Order
Delicious gourmet cookies are now available to you 24/7! We require a minimum of 8 cookies per order and we ship WORLDWIDE. Check out our new flavors every week!
the goods!
Strawberry base with chunks of golden Oreos freeze dried strawberries and Belgian white chocolate...
Strawberry base with chunks of golden Oreos freeze dried strawberries and Belgian white chocolate chips stuffed with a homemade sweet strawberry creme filling. Topped with a homemade strawberry shortcake crumble.
$5.00
A Sugar cookie base with caramelized belgian white chocolate chips , rainbow sprinkles, stuffed w...
A Sugar cookie base with caramelized belgian white chocolate chips , rainbow sprinkles, stuffed with a cake-bite center
$5.00
Blue sugar based cookie stuffed with homemade Triple C dough and a double stuff Oreo
Blue sugar based cookie stuffed with homemade Triple C dough and a double stuff Oreo
$5.25
Our very own Fat Paulie's favorite- Chocolate chip cookie STUFFED with caramel M&Ms, brownie ...
Our very own Fat Paulie's favorite- Chocolate chip cookie STUFFED with caramel M&Ms, brownie bites and double stuffed Oreos.
$4.25
Chopped up Hersheys cookies n cream bar loaded with chopped up Oreos
Chopped up Hersheys cookies n cream bar loaded with chopped up Oreos
$4.50
super soft and comfortable Next Level 6210 Unisex Cotton-Poly tshirt
super soft and comfortable Next Level 6210 Unisex Cotton-Poly tshirt
$18.00 – $20.00
Gift card for your loved ones. these gift cards are electronic and will be emailed to you
Gift card for your loved ones. these gift cards are electronic and will be emailed to you
$10.00 – $100.00
Unisex Tri-blend next level crew T-shirt’s 50% polyester 25% combed ring spun cotton 25% rayon
Unisex Tri-blend next level crew T-shirt’s 50% polyester 25% combed ring spun cotton 25% rayon
$25.00 – $30.00
Brown sugar base with caramel chips and salted caramel center, topped with sea salt
Brown sugar base with caramel chips and salted caramel center, topped with sea salt
$4.25
Our signature Belgian chocolate chip mixed with graham cracker crumbles base stuffed with an Nute...
Our signature Belgian chocolate chip mixed with graham cracker crumbles base stuffed with an Nutella and a Jet-puffed marshmallow rolled in graham crackers
$5.00
blueberry pop tarts, Belgian white chocolate chips and just to make it better we mixed the batte...
blueberry pop tarts, Belgian white chocolate chips and just to make it better we mixed the batter with blueberry jam. You can taste the flavor in every bite. Topped with blue sanding sugar
$4.50
a sugar cookie base mixed with Belgian white chocolate and holiday sprinkles topped with star spa...
a sugar cookie base mixed with Belgian white chocolate and holiday sprinkles topped with star spangled sprinkles
$4.25
Belgian Dark chocolate chips, caramel chips, shredded coconut topped with a caramel dark chocolat...
Belgian Dark chocolate chips, caramel chips, shredded coconut topped with a caramel dark chocolate drizzle and shredded coconut
$4.50
Pumpkin spice cookie with heath bar crumbles mixed in the batter and sprinkled on top
Pumpkin spice cookie with heath bar crumbles mixed in the batter and sprinkled on top
$4.25
Peanut butter base mixed with Oreos and topped with Oreo crumbs
Peanut butter base mixed with Oreos and topped with Oreo crumbs
$4.25
More About Us
Who We Are
It all started with one cookie, family, and a first responder. Learn More about how Fat Paulie's Cookies came to be and why our cookies are the worst kept secret on the internet today.
FAQs
Our frequently asked questions can help you navigate everything from our ingredients, to shipping and more. Check out our FAQs if you have any questions before you purchase.
Get In Touch
For more information on larger wholesale orders or if you have general questions, please contact us at sales@fatpauliescookies.com for further assistance.